Site Meter The Attached Mother » Blog Archive » A forced thank you

A forced thank you

by

Last night after his soccer game, Bug received several compliments on his goalie skills.  (Yeah, he’s good :p)  He grinned and twisted his hair.  I told him to say thank you but he said (loud enough for us all to hear) “I’m too shy!”.  Everyone chuckled and I gave him a hug and we moved on.

Later I briefly wondered if I’d done the right thing by not insisting that he say thank you.  I came to the conclusion that I definitely had done the right thing.

Bug is not a rude child.  He says please and thank you regularly.  He is shy and having to speak to adults can be intimidating.  I have witnessed other parents forcing their children to say “please” and “thank you” or even to respond to a  “hello” from an adult.  I’ve seen children clam up and be near tears over a simple greeting.  What is the point of forcing a child into politeness?

I feel it is good discipline to remind a child to practice being courteous. I feel it is misled parenting to insist (much to the embarrassment of the child, the parent and the other adults involved) that a shy child be courteous.

Led by example!  When someone compliments you or performs a service for you, say thank you.  Use your manners and your child will see.  Be courteous and your child will learn how to be courteous also.

Reflect your child’s feelings.  Simply say, “I know you are feeling shy.  Adults can be intimidating.  Remember that being a polite person is something to be proud of.”  Let your child make the decision to be polite.  Remind them if they need it but don’t force them into courtesy.  It will backfire.

Another thing to consider is your own feelings. You probably feel embarrassed when your child forgets to say please, thank you or excuse me.  You feel it is a reflection on you and your parenting skills.  This might make you want to show that you DO, in fact, teach your child socially acceptable behaviour.  But, it’s not all about you.  You can make a lasting negative impression on your child by forcing them into politeness or you can be gentle with them and give them encouragement to try again next time.

Unrelated to my post, but still important, please check out this link.

img_58581.JPG


Leave a Reply


About The Attached Mother

The Attached Mother is about the real-life experiences of an attachment parenting mom. Allison writes about her parenting ideals such as co-sleeping, gentle discipline, child-led weaning, baby wearing and how she applies them with her three young sons.

The Attached Mother Author(s)

Blogging Flair

Parenting & Family Channel Posts

  • Monsanto Roundup
    With nine million litres of Roundup sold each year all over the world, the American agrochemical group Monsanto holds a world record. For the first time, a study led by Gilles-Eric Séralini [...]
  • What a proud parent does?
    So, there’s the looming talk of “candy at school” but thus far my son doesn’t seem to be any the wiser about how the whole “no more candy” came to be.  I’m trying to be objective, [...]
  • To prove I’m not the perfect parent
    My children are having a hard time with the fact that their mommy has been gone quite a bit lately.  And, I’m home now with no chance of traveling for quite some time and hopefully, if I do [...]
  • Cooking with Kids
    Bo is a great helper. I love to make cookies with Peanut. It's our fun mother/daughter activity. For a while, every time she took a nap, she'd ask if we could make chocolate chips when she [...]
  • Sleep: A Chance to Dream and For Mom to Get a Break
    I love sleep. It is in my top five of favorite things to do. Having a baby kind of ruins this though! The Little Guy is slowly getting better at sleeping. Many mornings, he's out cold at [...]
  • So, I really hate to complain but candy? Really?
    Here’s the deal.  You all know that my son is a talker and that thus far his teacher has been more than a little bit receptive to the fact that he NEVER.SHUTS.UP.  She seems to be [...]
  • Ok, so let’s talking Parenting…mmmkay?
    Ok, so yea, I get it, I’m a parent but not everyone wants to hear me tell parenting stories.  So, I figure, I’ll give you one little parenting story and then guide you in the direction of [...]
  • Do You Pull Up?
    The other day, I was working. I really was. I was doing some research, and I happened upon an article about Tori Spelling. She talked about her son, Liam's, potty training process. Here's a [...]
  • Electroshocking Toddlers?
    American psychiatry still regards electroconvulsive therapy as a respected treatment, even for kids. Although ECT for young children is nowhere near as common as for adults, most U.S. states [...]
  • Babies having babies.
    Mama always said that she was a 'baby that had a baby' when she got pregnant with me a mere WEEK after her wedding to Papa. She and I still look like sisters (I'm the YOUNGER one, dammit!), and we [...]

Hot Off The Press