Site Meter The Attached Mother » Blog Archive » More AP Myths

More AP Myths

by Allison Goines

When people think of AP’ers and parents who practice gente discpline, they tend to get a mental picture of a sugary-sweet mom asking “little Johnny” if he feels like behaving well today.  They picture parents who will attempt to make their children happy at any cost to themselves or others.

This, my friends, is not attachment parenting, nor is it gentle discipline.  As a mother it is not my job  to keep my children happy.  It is not my job to shield them from every disappointment that comes their way.  It is not my job to give them a steady source of everything they want.

It is my job to understand my child; to see his point of view in each situation.  I have to be proactive by not putting my child into situations that he cannot handle.  To be a good parent, I have to understand my child’s limitations due to age and circumstances and not force my child to do things that he is not capable of doing.

The real difference between an AP parent and an authoritarian parent looks something like this:  The AP parent would make an appointment at a time when she knows her child will not be tired or hungry.  She will prepare for the appointment by bringing along appropriate things to keep her child occupied while waiting.  When the child complains, the mother will express understanding and sympathy that waiting is indeed difficult and offer pre-planned, appropriate activities to fill the time.  Before the appointment she has discussed appropriate behaviour with her child and her child knows what is expected of him or her and why that behaviour is appropriate.

The authoritarian parent might make an appointment at the most convinient time for herself, regardless of her child’s needs.  She would expect her child to sit quietly and not complain about the wait.  She would become agigtated with any misbehaviour and likely threaten punishment.  There would be no understanding of the child’s feelings or she would simply not care to see things from the child’s point of view.

So, maybe you’re a little more attached and gentle than you thought. huh?  Attachment parenting is not some group of exclusive parents who coddle their children.  We simply use common sense and kindness to raise healthy (physically and emotionally) children.  We aren’t perfect parents.  In our less than stellar moments, we might yell or spank.  We get irritated with childish antics just like the next parent.  We have an ideal, however, that requires us to overcome shortfalls and realize when the problem lies with us as parents instead of blaming our frustration on our children.  We believe that discipline equates to teaching and not punishment.


6 Responses to “More AP Myths”

  1. Summer Says:

    Thank you so much for writing this! I get so tired of the myth about AP.

  2. Michael Davidsen Says:

    You said that well. We should all strive to really understand our children. Once I asked a former school administrator, a fairly strict person and not a vocal fan of attachment parenting, what he did if he found out he had asked his children to do something they weren’t capable of. He said that had never happened.

  3. SummerM Says:

    I’m tagging you to write about why you love blogging about AP. :)

    http://www.momisteaching.com/i-love-blogging-the-meme/

  4. Lets get it started! :: Mommy Babble Says:

    [...] and all the crazy, quirky things that comes from it. From celebs breastfeeding in public, being gentle without being permissive, to toys, toys, [...]

  5. Lori Says:

    Thank you, thank you, thank you! Well put :o)

  6. Summer Howerton Says:

    I am really enjoying your posts! I too am reading them all thinking that these are all the ways in which we parent our children but never knew there was a name for it. I am excited to read more on the subject!

Leave a Reply


About The Attached Mother

The Attached Mother is about the real-life experiences of an attachment parenting mom. Allison writes about her parenting ideals such as co-sleeping, gentle discipline, child-led weaning, baby wearing and how she applies them with her three young sons.

The Attached Mother Author(s)
    » Allison-Goines
    » Summer-M

Blogging Flair

Parenting & Family Channel Posts

  • Guest Post: Coming Out.
    I receive a lot of searches that deal with teenage sexuality, promiscuity, etc. both from the straight and gay point of view – the latter usually involving questions about coming out to friends and [...]
  • Lucky Foot Stuff
    With the new orthotic doing well…I guess…I've been reading more on bowing of the tibia. I have gotten a few responses from parents around the country reflecting our experience. It seems the [...]
  • Are All Toys Created Equal?
    My kids are like most, if you ask them what they would like for Christmas they will have no problem rattling off two- or twenty things they would like. As they get older there are more things [...]
  • Kuster Baby Products
    I am a huge fan of simple, minimalist approach to children's rooms and play areas. Although if you saw our play room you may think differently. Kuster is one company that offers very simple but [...]
  • Dear Kids Who Stole My Car Last Night...
    ...and I'm presuming you were kids, teenagers, etc. since we didn't actually catch you IN the act - we do know that you're short, as you managed to pull the seat way forward. Heh. And since we're [...]
  • Yea, Another Excuse
    I know it seems like I"m always coming up with one excuse or another but for now, I'm just in a funk.  My feed reader has 1045 in it right now....can I possibly read that much?  Well, that [...]
  • 6 months
    My baby turned 6 months old last week but my laptop is dying so I can't write about it. I will try and write the proper post I intended later but right now I have to save all my photos to disc. [...]
  • Some Fun
    We were bored one day... [...]
  • Just Curious
    Are you a better parent than your parents? ( surveys) [...]
  • Feeding Your Family On A Budget
    We are all aware how expensive it can be to have children, especially these days. For some reason they keep needing new clothes and want to be fed 3-4 times a day! That is why keeping a food [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes' 2nd Anniversary
    Can you believe it has only been two years? It seems that Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes have been married a lot longer than this, but that's it. Remember the days of Tom jumping on couches, [...]
  • Cheap eats: 7 diet tips from ‘Loser’ nutritionist
    Trim your food costs — and your waistline — with these simple tips Buy in bulk Bulk items are usually cheaper. That’s because there’s no expensive packaging included. Those savings are [...]
  • 10 Ways to Eat Healthy and Save Money
    Reduce the amount of prepackaged and processed foods you buy. If you can’t buy fresh, buy frozen. Take advantage of BOGO (buy 1 get one). Many groceries offer this with healthy foods. [...]
  • Masterpiece
    I think Jason Alexander will always be George Costanza to me...but this week he plays a serial killer. The above picture doesn't even look like him! Anyway, Newsday.com has a review of the [...]
  • Pictures from the Twilight World Premiere
    "Twilight" World Premiere at Mann Village on November 17, 2008 in Westwood, California. Technorati Tags: Twilight,Robert Pattinson,Kristin Stewart,Taylor Lautner [...]
  • Watching the View Off-Topic Thread November 18, 2008
    This is where you can talk about anything unrelated to The View. This thread is not monitored. [...]
  • Indigo plant may treat chronic skin disease
    Ointment helped ease psoriasis with fewer side effects, small study found Indigo naturalis, a dark blue plant used in traditional Chinese medicine, appears to be effective in treating psoriasis, a [...]
  • G.I. Joe Diorama Coolness
    While digging through my old picture files, I found a set of pictures that had been taken at Wizard World Chicago some years ago. The pictures are of a rather large G.I. Joe diorama that had been set [...]
  • She's Playing for the Men's League
    This is the stuff that only happens in the movies, isn't it? In Japan, 16 year old Eri Yoshida was surprisingly drafted in a men's baseball league after having successfully impressed the [...]
  • Hugh Laurie on Ellen
    I just got done watching Hugh's segment on Ellen and it was, of course, hilarious! If anyone finds a YouTube, please let me know and I'll put it up immediately! Anyway, Hugh came out and looked [...]